By now, you’ve probably heard “Make You Better,” the first song off of The Decemberists’ upcoming album What A Terrible World, What A Beautiful World. Perhaps you were one of the lucky few who got to see Colin Meloy busk with the song outside of a train station in Brooklyn, or you were one of the people who watched them perform the song on an old German TV show in the music video for the song. However, the band had not played the song live until last night, when they took to the stage on Conan. From the sound of things, they’re showing no signs of rust from their two-year hiatus. You can watch the performance below.